Homeowner advice

Gutter guards vs. gutter sealing: what each one fixes.

Gutter guards and gutter sealing fix two different problems. Guards cut down on the leaves and needles that land in the gutter. Sealing stops water dripping through the joints, mostly at the corners. If water is spilling over the front edge, you likely have a debris problem. If it is dripping from a corner or a seam underneath, you have a leak, and a guard will not fix it.

The short version

Water over the top edge usually means a clog, so think cleaning and maybe guards. Drips from a corner or seam underneath mean the sealant has let go, so think sealing. Guards do not stop leaks, and sealing does not stop clogs. Many homes need a clean first either way.

Close-up inside the corner of a white gutter, with a thick strip of fresh white sealant spread over the corner joint and older grey residue on the gutter floor around it
Fresh sealant over a gutter corner joint, the spot where most leaks start.

Two problems that look alike from the ground.

From the driveway, a gutter that is overflowing and a gutter that is leaking can look the same. You see water where it should not be, a wet patch on the patio, or a stained strip on the siding.

The trick is to watch where the water leaves the gutter during a rain. Water that sheets over the outside lip is going over the top. Water that drips from underneath, often in one steady spot, is coming through the gutter itself.

  • Over the top edge, along a stretch: usually a clog, a blocked downspout or a gutter that has lost its slope.
  • A steady drip from a corner: usually the corner joint has opened up.
  • A drip from a joint along the run, an end cap or where the downspout connects: also a seal problem.
  • A dark streak under one corner on the fascia or siding: a sign that corner has been leaking for a while.

What gutter guards do.

A gutter guard is a cover, screen or insert that sits over the top of the gutter. The idea is to let rain in and keep larger debris out, so leaves and pine needles are less likely to build up and block the downspouts.

Guards can help, but they do not make a gutter maintenance-free. Fine debris like roof grit, seeds and broken-down needles can still get through or settle on top. Pine needles in particular can wedge into screens. Gutters with guards still need a check and a clean from time to time, and the guards may have to come off for the job.

Most important for this question: a guard sits on top of the gutter. It does nothing for a corner joint that is already leaking underneath.

What gutter sealing does.

Most homes here have long aluminum runs that only join at the corners, the end caps and the downspout outlets. Those joints are held watertight by sealant on the inside of the gutter. When that sealant cracks, shrinks or peels away, water finds the gap.

Sealant does not last forever. Our hot, dry Okanagan summers and cold winters make the metal expand and shrink with the seasons, and the joints take that movement. Sun, ice and standing water all wear the sealant down over time.

Sealing a corner properly means cleaning out the debris, scraping off the old, failed sealant, letting the joint dry, and laying a fresh layer of gutter sealant over the seam from the inside. Sealing over dirt or over the old material does not hold well. That is why sealing works best in dry weather, and why we clean the gutter first.

Which one does your home need?

If water spills over the top, start with a clean. Clear the leaves and needles, flush the downspouts, and see if the problem goes away. If your gutters fill up fast every fall because of big trees right over the roof, guards may be worth asking about.

If water drips from the corners or seams, the fix is sealing, not guards. A clean on its own will not stop a leaking joint, but it does need to happen first so the new sealant has something clean to stick to.

Plenty of homes have both problems. A clogged gutter holds standing water against every joint, which puts more strain on old sealant. Clearing the debris and resealing the leaking corners together deals with both.

Things sealing will not fix.

Sealant closes a gap in a sound joint. It cannot hold together a gutter that has a bigger problem. If a corner is badly bent or corroded, if a section has pulled away from the fascia, or if the gutter runs the wrong way and water pools in the middle, those need a repair or a replacement section.

A resealed joint can also start leaking again years down the road, because the same weather keeps working on it. When we are up there, we tell you what we see, including anything sealing will not solve.

Get your gutters looked at.

At Beam’s, gutter cleaning includes removing the leaves, needles and roof debris, flushing the downspouts and hauling the debris away, with photos of the cleaned gutters when we are done. Gutter cleaning starts at $225. If you have guards fitted, or a corner that drips, tell us when you ask for a quote so we can look at it and price it properly.

Not sure if it is a clog or a leak? Next time it rains, take a phone photo of where the water comes out and send it with your request. Book a free quote online or call us at 778-583-5057.

Common questions

Will gutter guards stop my gutters from leaking?

No. Guards keep larger debris out of the gutter. A leak at a corner or seam comes from failed sealant underneath, and that needs sealing.

Do I still need gutter cleaning if I have guards?

Yes, just less often in many cases. Fine debris and needles can still build up in or on the guards. Let us know you have them when you ask for a quote.

Why do the corners leak first?

Corners are joints, held together by sealant. The metal moves with hot and cold weather, and over time the sealant cracks or pulls away.

Can you seal a corner in the rain?

Not well. Sealant needs a clean, dry joint to stick, so sealing is best done in dry weather after the gutter has been cleaned.

Ready to plan your clean?

See what the service includes, or request a free quote for your property.

Explore gutter cleaningGet a Free Quote
Call Free Quote
Beam’s
Window Cleaning

Let’s talk about your clean.

Have a question about your windows, gutters or exterior cleaning? Send a text to the crew.

Open Messages

Opens your messaging app. You review and send.